Who is the most talented out of Roger Waters, David Gilmour and Syd Barret, State Reasons Why?

Dave Gilmour...Go listen to Comfortably numb, and get back to me....Just that song alone, kills me.. His guitar playing is so freakin unique and special..No one plays like him. He is just so perfect in everything he plays.....it's hard to describe..Just listen to his tone, his pion, his heart being thrown out there, when he plays. It's so pure.